Updated for 2025

Care-Specific vs
Generic HR Software

Compare Statixs with BrightHR, BambooHR, and Ciphr. See why care homes need specialized software with built-in CQC compliance.

Start Free Trial

Feature Comparison

Why Generic HR Software
Doesn't Work for Care Homes

BrightHR, BambooHR, and Ciphr are excellent general HR platforms, but they lack care-specific features for CQC compliance.

Feature
Statixs
£5/user
BrightHR
£4/user
BambooHR
£6/user
Ciphr
£8/user
CQC Reporting
Included
Not included
Not included
Not included
Staff Scheduling
Included
Add-on £3
Not included
Add-on module
Training Tracking
Included
Basic
Add-on LMS
Add-on £5
DBS Checks
£49.50 (at cost)
Not available
Not available
3rd party
Setup Fee
£0
£300-500
£800-1,200
£1,000-1,500

Cost Comparison

The Value of Care-Specific Software

Similar costs, but only Statixs includes CQC compliance and care-specific features

20-person care home
Statixs
£100/month
Generic HR
£120-180/month
Plus CQC compliance, DBS & care features
50-person care home
Statixs
£250/month
Generic HR
£300-450/month
Plus CQC compliance, DBS & care features
100-person facility
Statixs
£500/month
Generic HR
£600-900/month
Plus CQC compliance, DBS & care features

Detailed Analysis

What Generic HR Software Does Well
(And What They're Missing)

BrightHR

Strengths
  • Low base price
  • Simple HR basics
  • Mobile app included
Limitations
  • No CQC features
  • No DBS processing
  • Not care-specific
  • Limited scheduling

BambooHR

Strengths
  • User-friendly interface
  • Good HR features
  • Established platform
Limitations
  • No CQC compliance
  • No care-specific features
  • No scheduling
  • No DBS checks

Ciphr

Strengths
  • Comprehensive HR suite
  • Advanced reporting
  • Good support
Limitations
  • No CQC features
  • Expensive with modules
  • Not care-specific
  • Complex setup

Why It Matters

Critical Features Generic HR
Software Can't Provide

DBS Check Costs Matter

Most competitors mark up Enhanced DBS checks by £10-20 per check. For a 50-person care home processing 20 DBS checks annually, that's £200-400 in hidden costs.

Statixs charges the exact government cost of £49.50 with zero markup.

Read our Complete DBS Checks Guide

CQC Compliance is Non-Negotiable

Software that charges extra for CQC reporting puts compliance at risk. Your compliance tools should be built-in, not an expensive add-on.

Statixs includes comprehensive CQC compliance tracking at no extra cost.

Learn About CQC Compliance

Setup Fees Add Up Quickly

Competitor setup fees range from £300 to £2,000. For multi-site operators, these costs multiply per location.

Statixs has zero setup fees and provides free onboarding support.

True Cost of DBS Checks in 2025

Inspection Readiness

CQC inspections can happen with just 2 days notice. Your software should generate complete audit trails and compliance reports instantly.

Statixs provides one-click CQC inspection reports covering all 5 Key Questions.

Complete CQC Inspection Checklist

When Generic HR Software Makes Sense
(And When It Doesn't)

Here's our honest take on generic HR software for care homes:

  • Good for basic HR: BrightHR, BambooHR, and Ciphr excel at standard HR functions (contracts, holiday tracking, basic rota). But they lack CQC-specific features care homes need.
  • No CQC compliance built-in: None of these platforms include CQC compliance tracking, inspection reports, or fundamental standards mapping - critical for care homes.
  • No DBS processing: Enhanced DBS checks must be handled separately through third parties, adding complexity and cost. Statixs processes DBS checks at cost (£49.50).
  • Best use case for generic HR software: Non-care businesses or very large care groups with dedicated compliance teams who can handle CQC requirements separately.

Software Comparison Questions

Common questions when choosing between care-specific and generic HR software

Look, Person Centred Software is a solid product - they've been around for years and lots of care homes use them. But you're probably paying £26-30 per user per month once you add scheduling, compliance, and training modules. That's 5-6× more expensive than Statixs for essentially the same features. What you get with both: CQC compliance tracking, staff scheduling and rotas, training record management, DBS application handling, mobile apps for staff. Where Statixs is better: Price - £5/user all-in vs £26/user with add-ons. DBS cost - £49.50 exact vs £65-70 with markup. Setup - £0 vs £800-1,500 implementation fee. Where Person Centred might be better: If you're heavily integrated with other Person Centred products, switching might be disruptive. If you've got very specific customizations they've built for you. Honest take: For most care homes, Statixs delivers the same value at a fraction of the cost. Person Centred is a good product, just overpriced. Try Statixs free for 30 days and see if you actually need those expensive extras.
Nourish has good scheduling - we'll give them that. Their rota system is pretty intuitive. But here's the thing: Scheduling comparison: Both have drag-and-drop rotas, shift pattern templates, conflict detection, Working Time Regulations alerts, staff availability requests, mobile app for staff to view rotas. Price comparison: Nourish: £12/user base + £6 compliance module = £18/user minimum. Statixs: £5/user with compliance included. For 50 staff: Nourish = £900/month, Statixs = £250/month. Where Nourish gets expensive: Add-on modules for advanced features, setup fees of £1,000-1,500, complex pricing that makes budgeting difficult. Where Statixs is simpler: One price for everything, no surprise charges, includes features Nourish charges extra for. Real talk: Nourish's scheduling is good, but you're paying £13/user premium over Statixs for essentially the same functionality. That's £650/month (£7,800/year) extra for a 50-person home. Is slightly better scheduling UI worth £8,000 annually? Probably not.
Care Control targets large NHS trusts and big care groups with complex needs. They charge £18/user because their software is comprehensive and feature-rich - probably more than most care homes actually need. Care Control strengths: Very detailed reporting and analytics, extensive integration options, handles complex organizational structures, good for 200+ staff environments. Care Control weaknesses: Steep learning curve (takes weeks to train staff), expensive implementation (£1,500-2,000 setup fees), overcomplicated for typical 50-person care homes, costs £18/user (vs Statixs £5/user). Who should use Care Control: Large NHS trusts with 500+ healthcare staff, big care groups with very complex reporting needs, organizations with dedicated IT teams who can handle complexity. Who should use Statixs: Pretty much everyone else - typical care homes with 10-150 staff, nursing homes, domiciliary care agencies. Savings: 50-person home pays £900/month for Care Control vs £250/month for Statixs = £7,800/year saved. Unless you genuinely need their advanced features (most homes don't), you're paying a massive premium for functionality you'll never use.
Yep, and it's honestly a bit shameful. Government DBS cost (official rates): Enhanced with Barred Lists: £49.50. Basic/Standard: £21.50. These are the prices charged by the Disclosure and Barring Service directly. What competitors charge: Person Centred Software: £65-70 Enhanced (£15-20 markup). Nourish Care: £60-65 Enhanced (£10-15 markup). Care Control Systems: £62-68 Enhanced (£12-18 markup). What Statixs charges: £49.50 Enhanced (exact government cost, zero markup). Why this matters: Care homes do 10-20+ DBS checks per year. At £15/check markup × 15 checks = £225/year competitors are pocketing. Over 5 years = £1,125 in unnecessary markups. Why we don't mark up DBS: We think it's wrong to profit from mandatory legal requirements. You're already paying us £5/user for software - we don't need to squeeze extra profit from compliance costs. It's the principle of transparent pricing vs hidden markups. Some might say "it's only £15," but multiply that across hundreds of care homes doing thousands of DBS checks annually, and competitors are making millions from these markups while telling you they're 'including' DBS in the platform.
Honest answer: Yes, a few scenarios: If you're already heavily integrated with a competitor's ecosystem - For example, if you use Person Centred's care planning software, electronic care records, and family portal, switching just the HR component might create headaches. If you need very specific niche features - Some competitors have specialized modules we don't (yet). Like if you need advanced workforce analytics with predictive staffing models, Care Control might be better. If you're a massive NHS trust with 1,000+ staff - You might need enterprise features and dedicated account management that comes with expensive software. If you want an established brand - Some procurement departments feel safer buying from 20-year-old companies rather than newer entrants like Statixs (founded 2020). If you have unlimited budget - If cost genuinely doesn't matter, you might prefer the most expensive option assuming it's the best (not always true). For 95% of care homes though: Statixs delivers everything you need at a fraction of the cost. We're not trying to be everything to everyone - we're focused on being the best value HR and compliance platform for typical UK care providers. If you fall into one of those edge cases above, fair enough. But most homes will save £5,000-20,000 annually by switching to Statixs without losing any functionality they actually use.

Try Statixs Free
for 30 Days

No credit card required. Compare features yourself. Switch from your current provider with zero setup fees.

Start Free Trial

£5/user/month after trial · All features included · Cancel anytime